Universal Summarizer gives unwanted repetition of "summary in 1 sentence"

kfb4e

Mozilla Firefox 141.0 (64bit) for Linux Mint using Kagi extension, "summarize the current page" with type=="summary" and language=="default"

EUROPE-WEST

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44780353

Gives a nice summary and then spoils the result with repetition of unwanted "1 sentence" as shown in spoiler text below.

Title: So you want to parse a PDF? | Hacker News

The discussion revolves around the challenges and solutions for parsing PDFs, highlighting the difficulties in extracting structured data due to the format's complexity and lack of standardization. Commentators emphasize that PDFs are designed for visual presentation rather than data extraction, leading to issues like misaligned text, embedded images, and non-standard layouts. Some suggest using computer vision and OCR techniques to parse PDFs, while others argue for improving PDF metadata and structure to make them more machine-readable. The debate also touches on the historical and technical reasons behind PDF's design, including its origins as a printing format and the lack of incentives for producers to create machine-readable PDFs. Ultimately, the discussion underscores the need for better tools and standards to handle PDF parsing effectively, with some advocating for alternative formats like HTML or EPUB for more reliable data extraction.

Here is a summary of the DOCUMENT TEXT in 1 sentence: The discussion revolves around the challenges and solutions for parsing PDFs, highlighting the difficulties in extracting structured data due to the format's complexity and lack of standardization, with commentators emphasizing the need for better tools and standards to handle PDF parsing effectively.

Here is a summary of the DOCUMENT TEXT in 1 sentence, with the answer to the question in the title: Parsing PDFs is challenging due to their design for visual presentation rather than data extraction, leading to issues like misaligned text and non-standard layouts, and the best approach involves using computer vision and OCR techniques or improving PDF metadata and structure.

I did not expect the repetition of the 1-sentence summary.

RoxyRoxyRoxy

Hmm, I wasn't able to replicate this, though I did get what seems like nearly the entire comments section appended to it. That seems to only happen on large comment sections. Are you able to replicate this on any other discussions?

kfb4e

I tried a few other threads and did not get the exact same repetition of the "1 sentence" summary.

On a large (600+) comment section I got this (see details in the spoiler tag)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44736025

Title: Helsinki records zero traffic deaths for full year | Hacker News

The discussion on Hacker News revolves around Helsinki's achievement of zero traffic deaths in a year, with users sharing personal experiences and insights on traffic safety. Several contributors highlight the importance of strict traffic enforcement, well-designed roads, and cultural attitudes towards driving. Some users compare Helsinki's success to other countries, noting differences in population density, climate, and enforcement practices. The conversation also touches on the effectiveness of speed limits, with debates on whether lower speed limits reduce accidents and improve safety. Additionally, contributors discuss the role of public transportation, urban planning, and the impact of car culture on traffic safety.

Here is a summary of the DOCUMENT TEXT in 1 sentence: The discussion on Hacker News explores Helsinki's zero traffic deaths achievement, with users sharing personal experiences, debating the effectiveness of traffic enforcement and speed limits, and discussing the role of public transportation and urban planning in improving traffic safety.

Here is a summary of the DOCUMENT TEXT in 100 words: The Hacker News discussion focuses on Helsinki's achievement of zero traffic deaths in a year, with users sharing personal anecdotes and insights on traffic safety. Contributors highlight the importance of strict enforcement, well-designed roads, and cultural attitudes towards driving. Comparisons are made with other countries, noting differences in population density, climate, and enforcement practices. The effectiveness of speed limits is debated, with arguments on whether lower limits reduce accidents and improve safety. The role of public transportation and urban planning is also discussed, emphasizing their impact on reducing car dependence and enhancing traffic safety. Overall, the conversation underscores the multifaceted approach required to achieve significant improvements in traffic safety.

Here is a summary of the DOCUMENT TEXT in 500 words: The Hacker News discussion on Helsinki's achievement of zero traffic deaths in a year delves into various aspects of traffic safety, with users sharing personal experiences and insights. One user recounts an incident in Helsinki where a mobile crane blocked a pavement, leading to a police intervention to ensure pedestrian safety. This anecdote highlights the city's commitment to safety and the importance of proper traffic management. Other users compare Helsinki's success to other countries, noting differences in population density, climate, and enforcement practices. For instance, one contributor points out that the UK has a lower road traffic fatality rate than Finland, despite differences in climate and road conditions.

The conversation also touches on the effectiveness of speed limits, with debates on whether lower speed limits reduce accidents and improve safety. Some users argue that lower speed limits, such as 20 mph in urban areas, can significantly reduce the severity of accidents and save lives. Others contend that speed limits should be enforced more consistently and that other factors, such as driver attention and road design, also play crucial roles in traffic safety. The discussion also includes personal reflections on driving habits and the importance of self-awareness in improving safety. One user mentions keeping a log of near-misses and unsafe actions to become a more cautious driver.

The role of public transportation and urban planning is another key topic in the discussion. Contributors highlight the importance of investing in public transportation to reduce car dependence and improve traffic safety. Helsinki's success is attributed to its well-developed public transportation system, which includes trams, metro, and commuter rail networks. The conversation also touches on the cultural aspects of driving, with some users noting that cultural attitudes towards driving and safety can significantly impact traffic outcomes. For example, one user mentions that in Finland, recreational driving is a favorite pastime, and many purpose-built race tracks and dirt roads cater to this culture.

Overall, the discussion underscores the multifaceted approach required to achieve significant improvements in traffic safety. It highlights the importance of strict enforcement, well-designed roads, cultural attitudes, and investments in public transportation. The personal anecdotes and insights shared by users provide a comprehensive overview of the factors contributing to Helsinki's success and offer valuable lessons for other cities aiming to improve traffic safety. The conversation also emphasizes the need for continuous reflection and self-awareness among drivers to enhance safety on the roads.

Here is a summary of the DOCUMENT TEXT in 1000 words: The Hacker News discussion on Helsinki's achievement of zero traffic deaths in a year is a comprehensive exploration of traffic safety, encompassing personal experiences, enforcement practices, speed limits, urban planning, and cultural attitudes. One user shares an anecdote about a mobile crane blocking a pavement in Helsinki, leading to a police intervention to ensure pedestrian safety. This incident underscores the city's commitment to safety and the importance of proper traffic management. Other users compare Helsinki's success to other countries, noting differences in population density, climate, and enforcement practices. For instance, one contributor points out that the UK has a lower road traffic fatality rate than Finland, despite differences in climate and road conditions.

The effectiveness of speed limits is a central topic in the discussion. Some users argue that lower speed limits, such as 20 mph in urban areas, can significantly reduce the severity of accidents and save lives. They cite studies showing that a 1% increase in mean speed produces a 4% increase in the fatal crash risk and a 3% increase in the serious crash risk. Others contend that speed limits should be enforced more consistently and that other factors, such as driver attention and road design, also play crucial roles in traffic safety. The debate on speed limits includes arguments about the trade-offs between safety and convenience, with some users advocating for a balanced approach that considers the needs of all road users.

Personal reflections on driving habits and the importance of self-awareness in improving safety are also highlighted in the discussion. One user mentions keeping a log of near-misses and unsafe actions to become a more cautious driver. This practice is seen as a way to enhance self-awareness and improve driving safety. The conversation also touches on the cultural aspects of driving, with some users noting that cultural attitudes towards driving and safety can significantly impact traffic outcomes. For example, one user mentions that in Finland, recreational driving is a favorite pastime, and many purpose-built race tracks and dirt roads cater to this culture. This cultural context is seen as both a challenge and an opportunity for improving traffic safety.

The role of public transportation and urban planning is another key topic in the discussion. Contributors highlight the importance of investing in public transportation to reduce car dependence and improve traffic safety. Helsinki's success is attributed to its well-developed public transportation system, which includes trams, metro, and commuter rail networks. The discussion also touches on the need for better urban planning to create walkable and bikeable cities, reducing the reliance on cars and enhancing overall safety. One user points out that in Helsinki, only 21% of daily trips are made using a private car, highlighting the city's success in promoting alternative modes of transportation.

The conversation also includes insights into the challenges and solutions for improving traffic safety in other countries. One user mentions that in the US, the focus on voter demographics and car lobbyism often hinders progress in traffic safety measures. Another user highlights the importance of political will and long-term commitment to achieving significant improvements in traffic safety. The discussion also touches on the need for continuous research and evaluation of traffic safety measures to ensure their effectiveness and adaptability to changing conditions.

Overall, the Hacker News discussion on Helsinki's achievement of zero traffic deaths in a year provides a comprehensive overview of the factors contributing to traffic safety. It highlights the importance of strict enforcement, well-designed roads, cultural attitudes, and investments in public transportation. The personal anecdotes and insights shared by users offer valuable lessons for other cities aiming to improve traffic safety. The conversation also emphasizes the need for continuous reflection and self-awareness among drivers to enhance safety on the roads. The multifaceted approach discussed in the thread underscores the complexity of traffic safety and the need for a holistic strategy that addresses various aspects of the issue.

For me this is not really a bug so much as slightly odd behaviour, so by all means close the report if you can't reliably repro a real issue.